Sugar Box NYC Menu and Prices
No matter what you are hungry for, you’ll find a huge variety of delicious dishes to satisfy you at the Sugar Box NYC's menu. Whether you go for a Cookie Dough Cupcake, Sugar Coated Sour Strawberry Gummy Swedish, Red Velvet Cake Ice Cream, Carrot Cup Cake or Cookie Dough Cake Batter Shake Sugar Box NYC's tasty cuisine will hit the spot.
Sugar Box NYC Menu Categories
Now let’s check out Sugar Box NYC's menu! You will find that the menu is divided into the following categories:
- Picked For You
- Recommended
- Cakes
- Fresh Cookies
- Brownie Bars
- Milk Shakes
- Ice Cream Sandwich
- Vegan Dairy Free Ice Cream
- Little Baby's Ice Cream
- Jeni's Ice Cream
- Oddfellows Ice Cream
- Ben and Jerrys Ice Cream
- Ample Hills Ice Cream
- Giffords Famous Ice Cream Quarts
- McConnells Ice Cream
- Van Leeuwans Ice Cream
- Gummy Sours
- Gummy Sweets
- Taffy
- Gifts
Here is the Full Menu for Sugar Box NYC
Now that you know what you will be paying to eat at Sugar Box NYC, here is the full menu of food options to choose from!
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
Picked For You | |
| Oddfellows Oatmeal Cookie Dough
| $12.95 |
| McConnell's Banana and Salted Caramel
| $14.95 |
| Moose Tracks
| $13.95 |
| Ben and Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
| $7.99 |
| McConnell's Double Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream
| $14.95 |
Recommended | |
Cakes | |
| Blackout Chocolate Cake
| $6.95 |
| Chocolate Cake
| $6.95 |
| Chocolate Nonpareil Cake
| $6.95 |
| Oreo and Cream
| $6.95 |
| Sprinkle Vanilla Cake
| $6.95 |
| Sprinkle Vanilla Cake (Cakes)
| $6.95 |
| Birthday Cake Batter Bites
| $8.00 |
| Brownie Cupcake
| $3.95 |
| Snickers Cupcake
| $3.95 |
| Apple Pie Cupcake
| $3.95 |
| Carrot Cup Cake
| $3.95 |
| Cookie Dough Cupcake
| $3.95 |
| Oreo Cupcake
| $3.95 |
| Red Velvet Cupcake
| $3.95 |
Fresh Cookies | |
| Double Chocolate Chip Cookie
| $1.95 |
| Double Chocolate Chip Cookie (Fresh Cookies)
| $1.95 |
| Sugar Cookie
| $1.95 |
Brownie Bars | |
| Chocolate Brownie Fudge Bar
| $4.95 |
| Caramel Nut Bar
| $4.95 |
| Oreo Cookie Bar
| $4.95 |
| Lemon Bar
| $4.95 |
Milk Shakes | |
| Cotton Candy Ice Cream Shake
| $9.00 |
| Chocolate Lover's Chocolate Shake
| $9.00 |
| Cake Batter Shake
| $9.00 |
| Cookie Dough Cake Batter Shake (Milk Shakes)
| $9.00 |
| Cookie Dough Cake Batter Shake (Milk Shakes)
| $9.00 |
| Sea Salt Caramel Truffle Shake
| $9.00 |
| Sea Salt Caramel Truffle Shake (Milk Shakes)
| $9.00 |
| Double Cookies and Cream Shake
| $9.00 |
| Green Mint Chip
| $9.00 |
Ice Cream Sandwich | |
| Milk Cult Vegan Avocado Ice Cream Sandwich
| $4.50 |
| Milk Cult Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
| $4.50 |
| Italian Bomba Gelato Cannoball Ice Cream Sandwich
| $5.95 |
| Hazelnut Truffle Bomba Ice Cream Sandwich
| $5.95 |
| Exotic Bomba Ice Cream Sandwich
| $5.95 |
Vegan Dairy Free Ice Cream | |
| Jeni's Texas Sheet Cake Non Dairy Frozen Dessert
| $16.95 |
| Jeni's Frose Sorbet
| $15.00 |
| Van Leeuwan Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
| $13.00 |
| Little Baby’s Chocolate Salt Malt Vegan Ice Cream
| $13.00 |
| Van Leuween Vegan Dark Chocolate
| $13.00 |
| Little Baby’s Lychee Lemonade Vegan Ice Cream
| $13.00 |
| Van Leeuwan Vegan Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
| $13.00 |
| Little Baby’s Speculos Vegan Ice Cream
| $13.00 |
| Jeni's Dark Chocolate Truffle
| $16.95 |
| Mcconnell's Turkish Coffee Vegan
| $13.00 |
| Mcconnell's Eureka Lemon and Marionberries Vegan
| $13.00 |
| Little Baby’s Vanilla Coconut Clove
| $13.00 |
| Mcconnell's Toasted Coconut Almond Chip Vegan
| $13.00 |
Little Baby's Ice Cream | |
| Little Baby’s Vanilla Cardamom Cream
| $11.00 |
| Little Baby’s Cinnamon Clove Ice Cream
| $11.00 |
| Little Baby's Chocolate Salt Malt Ice Cream
| $11.00 |
Jeni's Ice Cream | |
| Boston Cream Pie Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
| Blackout Chocolate Cake Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
| Lemon and Blueberries Parfait Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
| Fluffernutter Pie Ice Cream (Oddfellows Ice Cream)
| $16.95 |
| Savannah Buttermint Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
| Sweet Cream Biscuits Peach and Jam Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
| Brandied Banana Brulee Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
| Goat Cheese with Red Cherries
| $16.95 |
| Jenis Cream Puff Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
| Jenis Brambleberry Crisp Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
| Jeni's Green Mint Chip
| $16.95 |
| Jeni's Popcorn Peanuts
| $15.00 |
| Jenis Milkiest Chocolate Ice Cream
| $16.95 |
Oddfellows Ice Cream | |
| Oddfellows Banana Puddin
| $12.95 |
| Oddfellows Burnt Marshmallow
| $12.95 |
| Oddfellows Dark Chocolate Chunk
| $12.95 |
| Oddfellows Oatmeal Cookie Dough (Oddfellows Ice Cream)
| $12.95 |
Ben and Jerrys Ice Cream | |
| Gimme Smores Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Red Velvet Cake Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Banana Split
| $7.99 |
| Americone Dream Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Brownie Batter Core
| $7.99 |
| Cherry Garcia
| $7.99 |
| Ben and Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (Ben and Jerrys Ice Cream)
| $7.99 |
| Chunky Monkey Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Chubby Hubby Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Half Baked Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Milk and Cookies Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| New York Super Fudge Chunk Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Strawberry Cheesecake Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| The Tonight Dough Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Cinnamom Bun Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Phish Food Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
| Vanilla Caramel Fudge Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
| $7.99 |
Ample Hills Ice Cream | |
| Ample Hills Chocolate Milk and Cookies Ice Cream
| $12.00 |
Giffords Famous Ice Cream Quarts | |
| Maine Lobster Tracks
| $13.95 |
| Moose Tracks (Giffords Famous Ice Cream Quarts)
| $13.95 |
| Chocolate Brownie Crunch
| $13.95 |
McConnells Ice Cream | |
| McConnell's Banana and Salted Caramel (McConnells Ice Cream)
| $14.95 |
| McConnell's Chocolate Covered Strawberries Ice Cream
| $14.95 |
| McConnell's Cookies and Cream
| $14.95 |
| McConnell's Double Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream (McConnells Ice Cream)
| $14.95 |
| McConnell's Eureka Lemon and Marionberries Ice Cream
| $14.95 |
| McConnell's Sea Salt Cream and Cookies Ice Cream
| $14.95 |
| McConnell's Toasted Coconut Almond Chip Ice Cream
| $14.95 |
| McConnell's Salted Caramel Chip Ice Cream
| $14.95 |
| McConnell's Turkish Coffee Ice Cream
| $14.95 |
Van Leeuwans Ice Cream | |
| Van Leeuwan Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
| $12.95 |
| Van Leeuwen's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
| $12.95 |
Gummy Sours | |
| Sour Mix Gummy Candy
| $7.00 |
| Toxic Waste Super Sour Gummy Bears
| $7.00 |
| Mini Gummy Sour Sharks
| $7.00 |
| Sour Watermelon Gummy Bears
| $7.00 |
| Sour Power Green Apple Candy Belts
| $4.00 |
| Sour Power Berry Blue Candy Belts
| $4.00 |
| Sour Power Quattro Belts
| $4.00 |
| Sour Power Strawberry Belts
| $4.00 |
| Gimbal's Sour Lips
| $7.00 |
| Pink Skulls Swedish
| $7.00 |
| Sour Swedish Skulls
| $7.00 |
| Sour Skulls Mix
| $7.00 |
| Sour Peach Lips
| $7.00 |
| Mixed Sour Lips
| $7.00 |
| Sour Apple Wrenches
| $7.00 |
| Sours Tongues
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Chicken Feet Candy
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Red Hot Chilli Peppers Candy
| $7.00 |
| Sour Gummy Twin Cherries Candy
| $7.00 |
| Sour Gummy Bottles
| $7.00 |
| Sugar Coated Sour Strawberry Gummy Swedish
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Sour Creepy Giant Spiders
| $7.00 |
| Sour Cola Bottles
| $7.00 |
| Sour Strawberry Wrenches
| $7.00 |
Gummy Sweets | |
| Sweet Mix Gummy Candy
| $7.00 |
| Sweet Wild Berry Red Licorice Gummy
| $7.00 |
| Broadway Strawberry Wheels (Gummy Sweets)
| $7.00 |
| Broadway Strawberry Wheels
| $7.00 |
| Assorted Sweet Gummy Robots
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Bears Bubbly Champagne
| $7.00 |
| Sugar Love Swedish Hearts
| $7.00 |
| Strawberry Gummy Swedish
| $7.00 |
| Sweet Lips Gummy Swedish
| $7.00 |
| Rambo Melon Swedish
| $7.00 |
| Exotic Fruit Mix Gummy Candy With Fruit Flavors
| $7.00 |
| Mini Gummy Sharks
| $7.00 |
| Twelve Flavor Gummi Bears
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Worms Candy
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Ice Cream Cones Candy
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Brains Candy
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Teeth Candy
| $7.00 |
| Gummy Dinosaurs Haribo Candy
| $7.00 |
| Sweet Cola Bottles Haribo
| $7.00 |
| Sweet Gummy Twin Cherries
| $7.00 |
Taffy | |
| Pomegranate Taffy
| $7.00 |
| Blueberry Taffy
| $7.00 |
| Blue Raspberry Salt Water Taffy
| $7.00 |
| Chilli Mango Madness Taffy
| $7.00 |
| Cotton Candy Taffy
| $7.00 |
| Green Apple Taffy
| $7.00 |
| Orange Salt Water Taffy
| $7.00 |
| Watermelon Taffy
| $7.00 |
Gifts | |
| Giant Smarties in a Tin
| $10.99 |
There Is Something For Everyone At Sugar Box NYC
Now you have discovered the full menu and prices for Sugar Box NYC! As you can see, there is something which will hit the spot for every customer, and the food is all incredibly reasonably priced!