Sherwood Forest Coney Island Menu and Prices
No matter what you are hungry for, you’ll find a huge variety of delicious dishes to satisfy you at the Sherwood Forest Coney Island's menu. Whether you go for a Turkey Sandwich, Curly Fries with Cheese, Chicken Club Pita, The BIG Corned Beef or Chicken Wrap Sherwood Forest Coney Island's tasty cuisine will hit the spot.
Notice: The prices listed on this page are provided for reference only. The actual prices may vary depending on your Sherwood Forest Coney Island location.
Sherwood Forest Coney Island Menu Categories
Now let’s check out Sherwood Forest Coney Island's menu! You will find that the menu is divided into the following categories:
- Appetizers
- Fresh Salads
- Soup & Chili
- Classic Sandwiches
- Deli Sandwiches
- 8 Inch Subs
- Pitas
- Wraps
- Burgers
- Coneys
- Steak & Chops
- Stir Fry
- Hot Sandwiches
- Noni's Favorites
- South of the Border
- BBQ Ribs
- From the Sea
- BBQ Chicken
- Broasted Chicken
- Italian
- Melts
- Greek Specialties
- Sides
- Desserts
- Beverages
Here is the Full Menu for Sherwood Forest Coney Island
Now that you know what you will be paying to eat at Sherwood Forest Coney Island, here is the full menu of food options to choose from!
Item | Price |
---|---|
Appetizers | |
6 Pc. Wing Dings
| $4.95 |
9 Pc. Wing Dings
| $6.45 |
5 Pc. Chicken Strips
| $6.35 |
16 Pc. Fried Mushrooms
| $4.95 |
6 Pc. Cheese Stix
| $4.95 |
8 Pc. Chicken Nuggets
| $4.50 |
Onion Rings
| $3.45 |
Jalapeños Poppers (6 pieces)
| $3.95 |
Saganaki
| $5.75 |
21 Pc. Shrimp Basket
| $5.95 |
Fried Clams
| $5.95 |
15 Pc. Smelt
| $5.95 |
Fresh SaladsAll salads are made with a blend of romaine, mixed greens and iceberg lettuce and include pita bread and your choice of dressing. Dressings: italian, greek, blue cheese, honey mustard, french, 1,000 island, ranch, caesar, raspberry vinaigrette, oil and vi | |
Nonis Special Salad
| $8.75 |
Turkey Salad
| $7.95 |
Grilled Salmon Salad
| $10.95 |
Cobb Salad
| $8.75 |
Chef Salad
| $7.95 |
Chicken Chef
| $9.65 |
Chicken or Tuna Salad Platter
| $7.95 |
Dinner Salad
| $3.45 - $4.95 |
Greek Salad
| $6.95 |
Greek Salad - Baby Greek Salad
| $5.95 |
Greek Salad - Chicken Greek Salad
| $8.95 |
Caesar Salad
| $6.25 |
Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken
| $8.25 |
Grilled Chicken Breast Salad
| $7.95 |
Strawberry Chicken Salad
| $8.95 |
Chicken Strip Salad
| $7.95 |
Soup & Chili | |
Soup of the Day
| $2.75 - $3.45 |
Cup of Soup and House Salad
| $5.75 |
Chili Plain (No Beans)
| $2.95 |
Chili Special
| $3.75 |
Classic SandwichesMake it a deluxe with your choice of two of the following: Soup, salad, coleslaw, fries or pop. 3.25, Add cheese for $0.50 | |
Grilled Ham & Cheese
| $5.45 |
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
| $5.65 |
Fish Sandwich
| $6.25 |
Fried Chicken Sandwich
| $4.95 |
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
| $3.25 |
Bacon Grilled Cheese
| $5.25 |
Chicken Salad Sandwich
| $5.95 |
Tuna Salad Sandwich
| $5.95 |
B.L.T.
| $4.75 |
Turkey Sandwich
| $5.95 |
Deli SandwichesAdd cheese for .50. Make it a deluxe with your choice of two of the following: Soup, salad, coleslaw, fries or pop. $3.25 | |
Nonis Combo
| $7.95 |
Pastrami Sandwich
| $7.55 |
Reuben Sandwich
| $7.25 |
Corned Beef Sandwich
| $6.85 |
The BIG Corned Beef
| $8.95 |
Nonis Club
| $7.25 |
Nonis Club With Slow-Roasted Turkey
| $6.95 |
Nonis Club With Thick Ham Slices
| $6.95 |
8 Inch SubsMake it a deluxe with your choice of two of the following: Soup, salad, coleslaw, fries or pop. 3.25 Add cheese for $0.50 | |
Philly Steak Sub
| $6.95 |
Grilled Chicken Sub
| $6.95 |
Turkey Sub
| $6.95 |
Ham & Cheese Sub
| $6.95 |
Nonis Sub
| $7.45 |
Chicken Supreme Sub
| $7.45 |
PitasAdd cheese for $0.50. Make it a deluxe with your choice of two: Soup, salad, coleslaw, fries or pop 3.25 | |
Grilled Chicken Pita
| $6.15 |
Club Pita
| $6.45 |
Gyro Pita
| $5.75 |
Turkey Pita
| $5.65 |
Philly Steak & Cheese Pita
| $6.75 |
1/2 lb. Corned Beef Pita
| $6.95 |
Chicken Club Pita
| $6.95 |
Noni's Delight Pita
| $7.25 |
Veggie Pita
| $4.75 |
B.L.T. Pita
| $5.45 |
Ham & Cheese Pita
| $5.75 |
Chicken Strip Pita
| $5.75 |
1/2 lb. Pastrami Pita
| $7.25 |
Chicken Greek Pita
| $6.95 |
Tuna Pita
| $5.95 |
WrapsAdd cheese for $0.50. Make it a deluxe with your choice of two: Soup, salad, coleslaw, fries or pop. 3.25. Add chili to fries for $1.95 | |
Chicken Wrap
| $6.15 |
Turkey & Swiss Wrap
| $6.15 |
Ham & Cheese Wrap
| $6.15 |
Chicken Club Wrap
| $6.75 |
Albacore Tuna Salad Wrap
| $5.95 |
Chicken Greek Wrap
| $6.95 |
B.L.T. Wrap
| $5.95 |
Philly Steak Wrap
| $6.75 |
Burgers1/2 lb. 100% beef, served with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and pickles. Make it a deluxe with your choice of two of the following: Soup, salad, coleslaw, fries or pop. 3.25 | |
Hamburger
| $4.25 |
Cheeseburger
| $4.75 |
Double Cheeseburger
| $5.95 |
Bacon Burger
| $5.25 |
Bacon Cheeseburger
| $5.75 |
Double Bacon Cheeseburger
| $6.95 |
Mushroom & Swiss Burger
| $5.95 |
Turkey Burger
| $5.95 |
Coneys | |
Hot Dog
| $1.85 |
Coney Island
| $2.25 |
Nonis Special
| $3.35 |
Loose Burger
| $2.75 |
Steak & ChopsServed with freshly baked rolls, choice of potato and your choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. | |
Pork Chops
| $9.55 |
Chopped Sirloin Steak
| $9.55 |
N.Y. Strip Steak
| $14.50 |
N.Y. Strip Steak & Grilled Chicken Breast Combo
| $19.95 |
N.Y. Strip Steak & 8 Pc. Jumbo Shrimp Combo
| $21.95 |
Stir FryFresh vegetables sautéed in a delicious brown sauce served on a bed of rice pilaf with pita bread. Includes your choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. | |
Grilled Chicken
| $9.95 |
Veggie Stir Fry
| $8.45 |
Marinated Steak
| $13.95 |
Shrimp Stir Fry
| $11.95 |
Combo Stir Fry With Chicken And Shrimp
| $15.95 |
Combo Stir Fry with Steak and Chicken
| $17.95 |
Combo Stir Fry with Steak and Shrimp
| $21.95 |
Hot SandwichesServed open-faced with vegetables, mashed potatoes and gravy. Your choice of | |
Hot Veal
| $7.95 |
Hot Meatloaf
| $7.95 |
Hot Roast Beef
| $7.95 |
Hot Turkey
| $7.95 |
Hot Ham
| $7.95 |
Hot Hamburger
| $7.95 |
Noni's FavoritesServed with freshly baked rolls, choice of potato and your choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. | |
Nonis Homemade Chicken Pot Pie
| $9.25 |
Roast Turkey Dinner
| $9.25 |
Chicken Strip Dinner
| $8.55 |
Baby Beef Liver & Onions
| $8.45 |
Stuffed Cabbage
| $9.25 |
Fried Chicken Dinner
| $4.35 |
Wing Ding Dinner
| $8.55 - $14.25 |
Chicken Breast Dinner
| $9.25 |
Chicken or Shrimp Alfredo
| $8.95 |
Chicken or Shrimp Alfredo with Chicken
| $10.95 |
Chicken or Shrimp Alfredo with Shrimp
| $13.95 |
Chicken or Shrimp Alfredo - Chicken and Shrimp Combo
| $18.95 |
Meatloaf Dinner
| $8.95 |
Stuffed Peppers
| $9.25 |
Lamb Shank Dinner
| $9.95 |
South of the Border | |
Steak Fajita
| $14.95 |
Chicken Quesadilla
| $8.25 |
Chicken Fajita
| $10.95 |
Super Nachos
| $6.25 - $8.25 |
Cheese Nachos
| $4.65 |
BBQ RibsServed with freshly baked rolls, choice of potato and your choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. | |
Baby Back Ribs
| $11.95 - $17.95 |
Ribs and Chicken Combo
| $16.95 |
Ribs and Shrimp Combo
| $18.95 |
Whole Slab Ribs & Chicken Combo
| $22.95 |
Whole Slab Ribs & Shrimp Combo
| $24.95 |
From the SeaServed with freshly baked rolls, choice of potato and your choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. Includes steamed vegetables, tartar or cocktail sauce and lemon wedges. | |
Fish and Chips
| $10.45 |
Lake Perch
| $13.45 |
Grilled Salmon
| $12.95 |
Tilapia
| $10.95 |
Fried Smelt
| $9.25 |
Shrimp Basket
| $8.95 |
Jumbo Shrimp Dinner
| $11.45 |
Fried Clams
| $9.25 |
BBQ ChickenServed with freshly baked rolls, choice of potato and your choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. | |
1/2 Baked BBQ Chicken
| $9.45 |
Whole Baked BBQ Chicken
| $14.95 |
Broasted Chicken | |
Leg & Thigh
| $7.95 |
Half Chicken
| $9.95 |
Whole Chicken
| $14.95 |
8 Piece Wing Dinner
| $10.95 |
Breast & Wing Dinner
| $7.95 |
4 Piece Dark Meat Dinner
| $8.95 |
2 Piece Chicken Breast Dinner
| $9.95 |
ItalianServed with freshly baked rolls and choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. | |
Lasagna
| $8.55 |
Italian Parmigiana
| $9.95 |
Italian Parmigiana with Veal
| $10.95 |
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
| $8.45 |
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce with Meatballs
| $10.95 |
Mostaccioli
| $8.65 |
MeltsServed with swiss cheese on grilled rye bread. Make it a deluxe with your choice Of two of the following: soup, salad, coleslaw, fries or pop. $3.25 | |
Tuna Melt
| $5.95 |
Patty Melt
| $5.75 |
Super Patty Melt
| $6.50 |
Chicken Melt
| $6.15 |
Super Chicken Melt with Bacon
| $7.25 |
Turkey Melt
| $6.25 |
Super Turkey Melt with Bacon
| $6.95 |
Greek SpecialtiesServed with freshly baked rolls and choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. | |
Shish Kabob
| $12.95 |
Chicken Kabob
| $9.45 |
Shish & Chicken Kabob Combo Platter
| $16.95 |
Gyro Platter
| $8.95 |
Spinach Pie
| $8.75 |
Sides | |
French Fries
| $2.25 |
Chili Fries
| $3.25 |
Cheese Fries
| $3.15 |
Chili Fries Special
| $4.95 |
Chili Cheese Fries
| $3.85 |
Potato Skins
| $4.95 |
Onion Rings
| $3.45 |
Curly Fries
| $2.95 |
Curly Fries with Cheese
| $3.65 |
Mashed Potatoes
| $2.25 |
Baked Potato
| $2.25 |
Rice Pilaf
| $2.25 |
Cottage Cheese
| $2.25 |
Coleslaw
| $2.25 |
Steamed Vegetables
| $2.25 |
Stir-Fried Fresh Vegetables
| $3.25 |
Pita Bread
| $1.25 |
Desserts | |
Fruit Pie
| $2.95 |
Ala Mode
| $3.50 |
Cream Pie
| $2.95 |
Cheesecake
| $2.75 |
Ice Cream (1 scoop)
| $1.85 |
Ice Cream (2 scoops)
| $2.75 |
Hot Fudge Sundae
| $3.25 - $3.95 |
Rice Pudding
| $2.25 |
Tapioca Pudding
| $2.25 |
Slice of Cake
| $2.95 |
Beverages | |
Coffee
| $1.85 - $2.25 |
Hot Tea
| $1.95 |
Hot Chocolate
| $1.95 |
Cappuccino
| $2.25 |
Bottled Water
| $1.25 |
Milk (White or Chocolate)
| $1.75 - $1.95 |
Juice
| $1.55 - $1.95 |
Soft Drinks
| $1.75 - $2.45 |
Iced Tea
| $1.95 |
Handmade Milk Shakes
| $3.95 |
There Is Something For Everyone At Sherwood Forest Coney Island
Now you have discovered the full menu and prices for Sherwood Forest Coney Island! As you can see, there is something which will hit the spot for every customer, and the food is all incredibly reasonably priced!