Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Menu and Prices
No matter what you are hungry for, you’ll find a huge variety of delicious dishes to satisfy you at the Shelsky's Of Brooklyn's menu. Whether you go for a The Fishless Sandwich, Dr. Brown's Soda, Baked Salmon Salad, The Great Gatsby Sandwich or Baked Salmon Salad Shelsky's Of Brooklyn's tasty cuisine will hit the spot.
Notice: The prices listed on this page are provided for reference only. The actual prices may vary depending on your Shelsky's Of Brooklyn location.
Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Menu Categories
Now let’s check out Shelsky's Of Brooklyn's menu! You will find that the menu is divided into the following categories:
- Beverages
- Simple Schmears
- Sandwiches
- Salads and Spreads
- Whole Smoked Fish
- Hand Sliced Smoked Salmon, Lox and Cured Salmon
- Specialty Sliced Smoked Fish
- Herring
- Sweets
Here is the Full Menu for Shelsky's Of Brooklyn
Now that you know what you will be paying to eat at Shelsky's Of Brooklyn, here is the full menu of food options to choose from!
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
BeveragesBeverages | |
| Bottle of Poland Spring
| $1.00 |
| Can of Seltzer
| $1.00 |
| Can of Diet Coke
| $1.50 |
| Dr. Brown's Soda
| $1.50 |
| Bottle of Mexican Coke
| $2.25 |
| Fizzy Lizzy
| $2.00 |
| Regata Ginger Beer
| $2.50 |
| Abita Root Beer
| $2.50 |
| Sprecher's Cream Soda
| $2.50 |
| Fentiman's Soda
| $2.50 |
| Ashlawn Farm Coffee
| $2.00 - $3.00 |
| Palais de Thes Tea
| $2.00 - $3.00 |
Simple SchmearsSimple Schmears | |
| Plain Cream Cheese
| $3.25 |
| Scallion Cream Cheese
| $3.50 |
| Ben's All Natural Cream Cheese
| $4.50 |
| Ben's All Natural Vegetable Cream Cheese
| $4.50 |
| Horseradish Cream Cheese
| $4.25 |
| Olive Cream Cheese
| $4.50 |
| Super Loxy Lox Cream Cheese
| $4.50 |
| Smoked Whitefish Salad
| $8.99 |
| Smoked Bluefish Salad
| $8.50 |
| Baked Salmon Salad
| $8.99 |
| Pickled Herring Salad
| $7.50 |
| Egg Salad
| $5.00 |
| Chopped Liver
| $8.50 |
| Butter
| $2.50 |
SandwichesSandwiches | |
| Member of the Tribe Sandwich
| $11.50 |
| The Fancy Pants Sandwich
| $15.00 |
| Peter Shelsky Sandwich
| $13.50 |
| Brooklyn Native Sandwich
| $13.50 |
| Brooklyn Transplant Sandwich
| $13.00 |
| Shelsky's Pastrami Sandwich
| $13.25 |
| Dr. Goldstein Special Sandwich
| $11.00 |
| The Great Gatsby Sandwich
| $12.50 |
| El Vincente Sandwich
| $15.50 |
| The Spicy Red Sandwich
| $12.00 |
| The Spicy White Sandwich
| $12.00 |
| Spicy Blue Sandwich
| $12.00 |
| The Holy Mackerel Sandwich
| $9.25 |
| The $20 Smoked Salmon Sandwich
| $20.00 |
| The Whitefish Club
| $12.00 |
| The Tribute Sandwich
| $13.00 |
| The Fishless Sandwich
| $8.50 |
Salads and SpreadsSalads and Spreads | |
| Smoked Whitefish Salad
| $14.50 - $22.00 |
| Smoked Bluefish Salad with Oranges, Fennel and Roasted Hazelnuts
| $13.00 - $20.00 |
| Baked Salmon Salad
| $14.50 - $22.00 |
| Homemade Chopped Liver (Chicken Livers)
| $8.50 - $12.99 |
| Plain Cream Cheese
| $4.79 - $7.25 |
| Scallion Cream Cheese
| $5.45 - $8.25 |
| Lox Cream Cheese
| $8.09 - $12.25 |
Whole Smoked FishWhole Smoked Fish | |
| Whole Smoked Red Trout
| $15.00 |
| Whole Smoked Whitefish
| $42.00 |
| Bering Cisco
| $21.00 |
Hand Sliced Smoked Salmon, Lox and Cured SalmonHand Sliced Smoked Salmon, Lox and Cured Salmon | |
| Hand Sliced Gaspe Nova Smoked Salmon for 2 People
| $11.99 |
| Hand Sliced New Brunswick Smoked Salmon for 2 People
| $9.99 |
| Hand Sliced Mild Scottish Salmon for 2 People
| $12.99 |
| Hand Sliced Double-Cure Irish Organic Salmon for 2 People
| $12.99 |
| Hand Sliced Wild King Salmon for 2 People
| $14.99 |
| Hand Sliced Ruby Red Wild Alaskan Sockeye for 2 People
| $21.99 |
| Hand Sliced Salty Belly Lox for 2 People
| $11.99 |
| Hand Sliced House Cured Gravlax for 2 People
| $13.99 |
Specialty Sliced Smoked FishSpecialty Sliced Smoked Fish | |
| Hand Sliced Smoked Sable for 2 People
| $16.99 |
| Hand Sliced Fatty Lake Sturgeon for 2 People
| $17.99 |
HerringHerring | |
| Small House Pickled Herring with Cream Sauce and Onions
| $7.00 |
| Small House Pickled Herring with Wine Sauce and Onions
| $7.00 |
| Small French Oak Smoked Herring Fillets
| $8.50 |
| Small Schmaltz Herring
| $11.00 |
| Small Matjes Herring
| $11.00 |
SweetsSweets | |
| 1 lb. Homemade Assorted Rugelach
| $14.50 |
| Homemade Chocolate Babka
| $14.50 - $40.00 |
| Mama Ilene's Coconut Macaroons
| $1.00 |
| Homemade Honey Cake
| $14.50 - $40.00 |
| Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt
| $4.00 |
| 2 Pieces Raspberry Rugelach
| $2.50 |
| 2 Pieces Apricot Rugelach
| $2.50 |
| 2 Pieces Chocolate Lingonberry Rugelach
| $2.50 |
| 2 Pieces Clementine and Ginger Rugelach
| $2.50 |
There Is Something For Everyone At Shelsky's Of Brooklyn
Now you have discovered the full menu and prices for Shelsky's Of Brooklyn! As you can see, there is something which will hit the spot for every customer, and the food is all incredibly reasonably priced!