Pappa's Coney Island Menu and Prices
No matter what you are hungry for, you’ll find a huge variety of delicious dishes to satisfy you at the Pappa's Coney Island's menu. Whether you go for a Cheeseburger, Cheeseburger, Greek Grilled Chicken Salad, Chef Salad or Greek Salad Pappa's Coney Island's tasty cuisine will hit the spot.
Notice: The prices listed on this page are provided for reference only. The actual prices may vary depending on your Pappa's Coney Island location.
Pappa's Coney Island Menu Categories
Now let’s check out Pappa's Coney Island's menu! You will find that the menu is divided into the following categories:
- Sandwiches
- Pita Sandwiches
- Submarine Sandwiches
- Coneys
- Chili
- Burgers
- Side Orders
- Salads
- Nachos
- Beverages
- Desserts
Here is the Full Menu for Pappa's Coney Island
Now that you know what you will be paying to eat at Pappa's Coney Island, here is the full menu of food options to choose from!
Item | Price |
---|---|
Sandwiches | |
Club Sandwich
| $4.85 |
Turkey Sandwich
| $3.50 |
Reuben Sandwich
| $5.00 |
Corned Beef Sandwich
| $4.50 |
Tuna Sandwich
| $3.55 |
Tuna Melt
| $3.80 |
Ham Sandwich
| $2.95 |
Grilled Ham & Cheese
| $3.60 |
Grilled Cheese
| $1.65 |
Blt
| $2.95 |
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
| $4.60 |
Fried Chicken Sandwich
| $3.00 |
Chicken Club Sandwich
| $4.40 |
Steak Sandwich
| $4.60 |
Fish Sandwich
| $2.95 |
Pita Sandwiches | |
Gyro
| $3.75 |
Chicken Delight
| $4.60 |
Grilled Chicken Pita
| $4.80 |
new Grilled Chicken Caesar
| $5.55 |
Ham Pita
| $4.35 |
Steak Pita
| $5.15 |
Tuna Pita
| $4.30 |
Turkey Pita
| $4.30 |
Corned Beef Pita
| $5.05 |
Submarine Sandwiches | |
Steak Hoagie
| $4.50 |
Philly Steak & Cheese
| $4.70 |
New Corned Beef & Cheese Sub
| $5.45 |
Mushroom Steak & Swiss
| $5.25 |
Grilled Chicken Sub
| $5.15 |
Tuna Sub
| $4.30 |
Ham & Cheese
| $4.50 |
Turkey Sub
| $4.30 |
Coneys | |
Plain Hot Plain
| $1.25 |
Coney Island
| $1.45 |
Coney Special
| |
Loose Burger
| $1.95 |
Coney Taco
| $2.55 |
Fire Dog
| $2.25 |
Kraut Dog
| $1.85 |
Fish Dog
| $2.35 |
Chili | |
Bowl Of Chili
| $2.25 |
Bowl Of Chili Special
| $2.75 |
Burgers1/4 lb. all beef patty on a sesame seed bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, ketchup, mayo & mustard. add chili on fries $1.10 extra. add chili & cheese $1.60 extra. deluxe orders include fries. | |
Hamburger
| $2.55 - $4.25 |
Cheeseburger
| $2.80 - $4.50 |
Bacon Burger
| $3.40 - $5.10 |
Bacon Cheeseburger
| $3.65 - $5.35 |
Double Burger
| $3.95 - $5.65 |
Double Cheeseburger
| $4.25 - $5.95 |
Double Bacon Burger
| $4.70 - $6.40 |
Double Bacon Cheeseburger
| $5.75 - $7.45 |
Chili Burger
| $3.15 - $4.85 |
Patty Melt
| $3.25 - $4.95 |
Mushroom & Swiss Burger
| $3.50 - $5.20 |
Side Orders | |
French Fries
| $1.60 |
Chili Fries
| $2.10 |
Chili Fries
| $2.70 |
Chili Fry Special
| $3.35 |
Onion Rings
| $2.50 |
Breaded Mushrooms
| $2.75 |
Cheese Sticks
| $3.10 |
Wing Ding Snack
| $4.05 - $12.35 |
Chicken Snack
| $5.25 |
Shrimp Basket
| $4.85 |
Side Of Corned Beef
| $3.00 |
Chicken Strips
| $5.50 |
Chicken Breast
| $4.00 |
Slice Of Turkey
| $1.65 |
New York Steak
| $4.00 |
Feta Cheese
| $1.50 |
Hard Boiled Egg
| $0.60 |
Ranch Dressing
| $0.50 |
Hot Peppers
| $0.65 |
Melted Cheese
| $0.60 |
Saladsall salads are served with pita bread & choice of dressing. cucumbers come in all salads except the chef salad. | |
Tossed Salad
| $2.45 |
Tuna Salad
| $5.65 |
Turkey Salad
| $5.65 |
Chef Salad
| $5.65 |
Greek Salad
| $5.65 |
New Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
| $7.25 |
New Chicken Finger Salad
| $6.45 |
Grilled Chicken Salad
| $6.70 |
Greek Grilled Chicken Salad
| $8.35 |
Nachos | |
Plain
| $2.20 |
With Cheese
| $3.65 |
With Meat & Cheese
| $4.35 |
Nacho Supreme
| $6.05 |
Beverages | |
Pop
| $1.00 - $1.55 |
Coffee
| $1.00 - $1.25 |
Hot Tea
| $1.05 |
Hot Chocolate
| $1.10 |
Milk
| $1.05 |
Juice
| $1.30 |
Desserts | |
Cake
| $2.10 |
There Is Something For Everyone At Pappa's Coney Island
Now you have discovered the full menu and prices for Pappa's Coney Island! As you can see, there is something which will hit the spot for every customer, and the food is all incredibly reasonably priced!