Nervous Nellie's Menu and Prices
No matter what you are hungry for, you’ll find a huge variety of delicious dishes to satisfy you at the Nervous Nellie's menu. Whether you go for a Nellie's Ultimate Steam Pot, Our Traditional Surf and Turf, Pan Tossed Shrimp 'N Scallop Salad, "Amazing" Grilled Salmon Oscar or Buffalo Chicken Salad Nervous Nellie's tasty cuisine will hit the spot.
Notice: The prices listed on this page are provided for reference only. The actual prices may vary depending on your Nervous Nellie's location.
Nervous Nellie's Menu Categories
Now let’s check out Nervous Nellie's menu! You will find that the menu is divided into the following categories:
- Apps 'N Good Olde Stuff
- Mains
- Shucked 'N Chilled
- Soups
- World Famous Caesars
- Some Wild 'N Crazy Sandwiches
- Famous Island Style BBQ
- Panini Predicament?
- Insane Reubens - Ole Time favorite!!
- Our "Naw'lines" Po-Boy
- Burgers with an Attitude!!!!
- Seafood And lot's Of It
- Nellie's Fresh Catch
- Enjoy With Any Kind of Weather
- Nellie's Famous Seafood Pots
- Steaks!! Steaks!! And More!
- Our Famous Steak Toppings
- Lotsa Pastabilities
- Crazy as can be!!! Quesadillas
- Please!!! Be A 'Basket Case'!!!
- Hook, Line and Sinker
- Cast A Spell
- Dessert of thr Moment!
- Frozen Smoothies
- What about the Kid's
- Coffee, Tea and More!
- Quenching Beverages
Here is the Full Menu for Nervous Nellie's
Now that you know what you will be paying to eat at Nervous Nellie's, here is the full menu of food options to choose from!
Item | Price |
---|---|
Apps 'N Good Olde Stuff | |
Nellie's Signature Shrimp Cocktail
| $12.95 |
Tavern Bread
| $10.95 |
Coconut Fried Shrimp
| $13.95 |
Blackened Shrimp and Grouper Bites
| $14.95 |
Shrimp and Scallops Bruschetta
| $13.95 |
Florida Gator Bites
| $13.95 |
Fried Green Tomato Stack
| $11.95 |
Homemade Mozzarella Planks
| $9.95 |
Drunken Wings
| $8.95 - $12.95 |
Crabmeat Stuffed Artichoke Dip
| $12.95 |
Crusty Fried Artichokes
| $9.95 |
Buffalo Chicken Salad
| $12.95 |
Oh Baby Greens!!
| $7.95 |
Crazy Cobb Salad
| $14.95 |
Ultimate Chilled Lobster Salad
| $19.95 |
Crazy Calamari 'N Shrimp
| $12.95 |
Seafood Quesadilla
| $15.95 |
Zesty Thai Shrimp Salad
| $13.95 |
The Wacky Wedge Salad
| $11.95 |
Pan Tossed Shrimp 'N Scallop Salad
| $16.95 |
Pineapple Chicken Salad
| $13.95 |
Already Famous Calamari
| $10.95 |
Florida Summer Salad
| $10.95 |
Nellie's Inspired Chef Salad
| $13.95 |
Mains | |
Steam'in Mussels
| $12.95 |
Devilish mussels
| $12.95 |
Rockies
| $12.95 |
World's Largest Shrimp and Maine Cocktail
| $27.95 |
World's Ultimate Lobster Roll
| |
Shucked 'N ChilledTo taste an Oyster is like tasting the cold ocean itself | |
Oyster On A Half Shell
| $9.95 - $15.95 |
Peel & Eat Chilled Shrimp
| $12.95 - $28.95 |
SoupsWe say every meal should revolve around a savory creation!! | |
Seize the Day!!!
| $6.95 |
Steam'in Onion Soup Au Gratin
| $6.95 |
Chowder of the day
| $7.95 |
World Famous CaesarsCreate your own fix'ins on top!!! | |
Plain our way!
| $9.95 |
Pan-Seared Ahi Tuna
| $17.95 |
Chilled Shrimp
| $14.95 |
Lobster Salad
| $19.95 |
Citrus Flame-seared Chicken Breast
| $12.95 |
Grilled Salmon
| $15.95 |
Some Wild 'N Crazy SandwichesAll served up with our famous plank fries and creamy cone slaw. On home baked bread to boot | |
Grab Your Grouper Sandwich
| $18.95 |
Fresh Haddock Sandwiches Your Way
| $13.95 |
Frenchy's Dip
| $13.95 |
The "Finest Kind" Cheese Steak
| $13.95 |
Our Favorite Cuban Sandwich
| $12.95 |
Our Own BLT
| $12.95 |
The "Big" Sandwich
| $13.95 |
Old fashioned Chicken Salad Sandwich
| $11.95 |
Famous Crunchy Fish Tacos
| $13.95 |
Mahi Mahi Soft Tacos
| $13.95 |
Fire-Seared Whiskey Chicken Sandwich
| $11.95 |
Beach Chicken Sandwich
| $12.95 |
Boom Boom Fried Chicken Sandwich
| $12.95 |
Oh Mahi Mahi Sandwich
| $16.95 |
Famous Island Style BBQAll of our friends brag about the way we cook them up !!! All served with tasty planks fries and BBQ baked beans-You'll be back!!!! | |
Famous Tavern Baby Back Ribs
| $16.95 - $22.95 |
Sweet Caroline's Baby Backs
| $16.95 - $22.95 |
Spicy Bourbon Baby Backs
| $16.95 - $22.95 |
Hi Country Combo
| $21.95 |
Wombo Combo
| $27.95 |
BBQ Pulled Pork Open-Faced
| $12.95 |
Panini Predicament?Our Gourmet individual Paninis are made from only the finest local ingredients, all handmade with TLC and rather natural!!!! All grilled on Artisan breads to a golden brown. Served up with Plank fries and tangy pickle wedge....Enjoy!!! | |
Tricky Turkey
| $11.95 |
BBQ Pulled Pork
| $11.95 |
Crabcake Melt
| $14.95 |
Grilled Vegetable
| $9.95 |
A Stav'in Panini
| $11.95 |
Insane Reubens - Ole Time favorite!!All these sandwiches are prepared on grilled homemade hand cut breads and require two healthy hands!!! Served up with plank fries and a tasty pickle | |
Two-Fisted Corned Beef Reuben
| $13.95 |
Oh! Turkey
| $11.95 |
Harbor Reuben
| $12.95 |
Most interesting Reuben in the World
| $19.95 |
Bronzed Grouper Reuben
| $18.95 |
Ridiculous Reuben
| $14.95 |
Our "Naw'lines" Po-BoyOur traditional French bread sandwich dressed with crisp romaine lettuce, ripe tomato, pickle and dressing - you make the call - All tender fried: | |
Plump Shrimp
| $13.95 |
Crispy Scallops
| $13.95 |
Rolled Oysters
| $13.95 |
Burgers with an Attitude!!!!Prime Cuts of beef, fresh never frozen. A full half pound Flames seared yo your liking! Served on our bakery roll with plank Fries, lettuce, tomatto and creamy cole slaw | |
The San Carlos Slammer
| $13.95 |
Whiskey Creek BBQ Cheeseburger
| $13.95 |
Santa Fe Blaze Burger
| $13.95 |
Ultimate Patty Melt
| $12.95 |
Sonoma Country Swiss burger
| $12.95 |
The "Philly"
| $12.95 |
Dreamful Cheeseburger
| $11.95 |
Seafood And lot's Of ItPick 2 of our fabulous sides! Choose from Wild Rice Pialf Fries, Smashed Potato, BBQ baked beans, Black beans & Rice, Chef's Vegetable, Fresh Seasonal Fruit, Cole Slaw and a basket or Fresh bread | |
Crunchy Fried Grouper
| $23.95 - $24.95 |
Our Sailor's Delight
| $20.95 |
Beachbake
| $20.95 |
Nellie's Famous Fried Shrimp
| $23.95 |
Island Style Coconut Shrimp
| $24.95 |
Stone Ground Mustard Baked Salmon
| $21.95 |
"Amazing" Grilled Salmon Oscar
| $24.95 |
Blue Crab Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp
| $24.95 |
Bimini Scallop Boat
| $25.95 |
Ultimate crab Cakes
| $17.95 |
Spiced Stuffed Scallops
| $27.95 |
Florida Broiled Seafood Platter
| $27.95 |
Nellie's Fresh Catch | |
Nellie's Fresh Catch
| $20.99 |
Enjoy With Any Kind of Weather | |
Nellie's Gumbo
| $17.95 |
Our Famous Seafood Pasta
| $20.95 |
Nervous Nellie's Incredible Island Jambalaya
| $19.95 |
Nellie's Famous Seafood PotsThe perfect shore dinner! choose your favorite seafood. We serve in a pot with streamed red bliss potatoes, carrots and corn on the cab. Enjoy a fresh bread basket from Nellie's Bakery | |
Nellie's Ultimate Steam Pot
| $36.99 |
Chef's Bounty Crab Feast
| $39.99 |
Island Steamed Crab Legs and Cluster
| $29.99 |
Maine Lobster Pot
| $29.99 |
Ale Steamed Jumbo Shrimp
| $23.99 |
Steaks!! Steaks!! And More!We are certainly proud these hand-out organic gems- We know will be as we!!! All these entered are served up with your choice of planks fries, smashed potatoes, BBQ baked beams and our specially prepared vegetable of the day. Plus freshly baked breads and butter. You may compliment your Dinner with a wonderful house salad for only $3.95 enjoy | |
Nellie's USDA Char- Grilled New York Srtip
| $21.95 |
Our 8 oz Filet Mignon
| $26.99 |
North and South
| $ |
Our Traditional Surf and Turf
| $ |
Our 8oz Filet Mignon
| $26.99 |
Our Famous Steak Toppings | |
Nellie's Steak Oscar
| $6.00 |
Sonama Country WIne and Mushroom Medley
| $3.00 |
Lotsa Pastabilities | |
Roasted Chicken Alfredo
| $16.95 |
Chicken Parmesan!
| $16.95 |
Four Cheese Tri-Color Tortellini and Jumbo Shrimp
| $17.95 |
Golden Macaroni and Cheese
| $14.95 - $19.95 |
Crazy as can be!!! Quesadillas | |
BBQ Chicken'N More
| $13.95 |
Southern BBQ Pork Quesadillas
| $13.95 |
Ragin' Cajin' Chicken & Sausage Quesadilla
| $13.95 |
Seafood Quesadilla
| $15.95 |
Very Veggie Quesadilla
| $10.95 |
Please!!! Be A 'Basket Case'!!!LL our basket served up real heartly-Enjoy sweet slaw and crsipy plank fries | |
Fried Jumbo Shrimp
| $17.95 |
Ale Battered Grouper
| $18.95 |
Oh! Chicken Fingers
| $11.95 |
Fried Clam Strips
| $14.95 |
Ale Battered Jumbo Shrimp 'n Fish
| $18.95 |
Crispy Jumbo Scallops
| $18.95 |
Golden Fried Shrimp and Scallops
| $19.95 |
Olde Fashioned Ale Battered Fish 'n Chips
| $14.95 |
Hook, Line and Sinker | |
Hook, Line and Sinker
| $25.95 |
Cast A SpellAll served up sizzlin' all the way to the table". Enjoy fluffy Jasmine rice as well. | |
Sizzling Steak and Chicken Fajitas
| $16.95 |
Ultimate Seafood Fajitas
| $18.95 |
jumbo Shrimp and scallops Stir-Fry
| $17.95 |
Thai Chicken Stir-Fry
| $15.95 |
Dessert of thr Moment! | |
Chocolate Mud Puddle
| $6.95 |
Florida Key Lime Pie
| $6.95 |
Mile High Carrot Cake
| $6.95 |
Frozen Smoothies$5.95 | |
Strawberry
| |
Banana
| |
Raspberry
| |
Peach
| |
Pina Coloda
| |
Mango
| |
Strawberry-Banana
| |
Mighty Chocolate
| |
What about the Kid'sIf the kids aren't happy, then Mama's not happy, then nobody's happy!!!; All for $6.99. 10 years old and younger - Please. We are serious about the Kid's menu!!! Only the freshest and finest ingredients - Enjoy!!! | |
Cheeseburger
| |
Chicken Fingers
| |
Creamy Mac and Cheese
| |
Our famous Hot Dog
| |
Roni's & Butter
| |
Lightly Fried Chicken Sandwich
| |
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
| |
Coffee, Tea and More!$2.99 | |
Fresh Ground
| |
Gourmet Coffees
| |
Hot Tea from
| |
Around the World
| |
Steam'in Hot Chocolate
| |
Quenching Beverages | |
Sweet Iced tea
| $2.99 |
Brewed Iced tea
| $2.99 |
Iced coffee
| $2.99 |
Milk
| $2.99 |
Chocolate Milk
| $2.99 |
juices
| $2.99 |
Fresh Squeezed Orange & Grapefruit Juice
| $2.99 |
Lemonade
| $2.99 |
Bottled Spring & Sparkling waters
| $2.99 |
Coca Cola
| $2.99 |
There Is Something For Everyone At Nervous Nellie's
Now you have discovered the full menu and prices for Nervous Nellie's! As you can see, there is something which will hit the spot for every customer, and the food is all incredibly reasonably priced!