Mehaffies Pies Menu and Prices
No matter what you are hungry for, you’ll find a huge variety of delicious dishes to satisfy you at the Mehaffies Pies menu. Whether you go for a Black Raspberry, Pecan, Sweet Potato, Pumpkin Roll or Sweet Potato Mehaffies Pies tasty cuisine will hit the spot.
Notice: The prices listed on this page are provided for reference only. The actual prices may vary depending on your Mehaffies Pies location.
Mehaffies Pies Menu Categories
Now let’s check out Mehaffies Pies menu! You will find that the menu is divided into the following categories:
- Fruit Pies
- Berry Pies
- Cream Pies
- No Sugar Added Pies
- Specialty Desserts
- Seasonal Pies
- Crunch Pies
- Frozen Pies
- "New York Style" Cheesecake
- Cakes
- Specialty Pies
Here is the Full Menu for Mehaffies Pies
Now that you know what you will be paying to eat at Mehaffies Pies, here is the full menu of food options to choose from!
Item | Price |
---|---|
Fruit Pies | |
Apple
| $8.25 |
Cherry
| $8.50 |
Dutch Apple
| $8.50 |
Peach
| $8.25 |
Pineapple
| $8.50 |
Pumpkin
| $8.50 |
Raisin
| $8.25 |
Berry Pies | |
Black Raspberry
| $9.00 |
Blackberry
| $8.25 |
Blueberry
| $8.50 |
Strawberry
| $8.50 |
Strawberry Rhubarb
| $8.25 |
Red Raspberry
| $8.75 |
Cream Pies | |
Peanut Butter
| $8.50 |
Banana
| $8.50 |
Butterscotch
| $8.50 |
Chocolate
| $8.50 |
Chocolate Peanut Butter
| $8.50 |
Coconut
| $8.50 |
Lemon Meringue
| $8.50 |
Sugar Cream
| $8.50 |
No Sugar Added Pies | |
Cherry (No Sugar Added Pies)
| $8.75 |
Apple (No Sugar Added Pies)
| $8.75 |
Peach (No Sugar Added Pies)
| $8.75 |
Specialty Desserts | |
Pumpkin Roll (6")
| $9.25 |
Pumpkin Roll Slice
| $2.25 |
Mini Pie (4")
| $2.00 |
Snails (4 Per Bag)
| $2.25 |
Pie Slice
| $2.00 |
Seasonal Pies | |
Mince
| $8.25 |
Sweet Potato
| $8.25 |
Crunch Pies | |
Apple Crunch
| $8.75 |
Cherry Crunch
| $8.75 |
Lemon Crunch
| $9.00 |
Peach Crunch
| $8.75 |
Frozen Pies | |
Key Lime
| $8.25 |
Creamsicle
| $8.25 |
"New York Style" Cheesecake | |
7" Plain
| $9.50 |
7" Turtle
| $10.75 |
9" Chocolate Chip
| $13.75 |
Cheesecake Slice
| $2.00 |
Cheesecake on a Stick
| $2.25 |
Cakes | |
Boston Cream
| $9.25 |
Carrot
| $9.25 |
Cake Slice
| $2.00 |
Specialty Pies | |
Custard
| $8.50 |
Pecan
| $9.00 |
There Is Something For Everyone At Mehaffies Pies
Now you have discovered the full menu and prices for Mehaffies Pies! As you can see, there is something which will hit the spot for every customer, and the food is all incredibly reasonably priced!