City Island Lobster House Menu and Prices
No matter what you are hungry for, you’ll find a huge variety of delicious dishes to satisfy you at the City Island Lobster House's menu. Whether you go for a Red Snapper Filet, Fried Calamari, Chillean Sea Bass, Freshly Shucked Fried Oysters or Paella (Serves one) City Island Lobster House's tasty cuisine will hit the spot.
Notice: The prices listed on this page are provided for reference only. The actual prices may vary depending on your City Island Lobster House location.
City Island Lobster House Menu Categories
Now let’s check out City Island Lobster House's menu! You will find that the menu is divided into the following categories:
- Appetizers - Cold
- Appetizers - Hot
- Soup
- Catch of the Day
- From our Fryer
- Lobsters
- Lobster House Crab Corner
- Chilled Shellfish Sampler
- Lobster House Feasts
- Lobster House Paella
- Mediterranean Dishes
- For Land Lubbers
- City Island Favorites
- Extraordinary Combinations
- Specials
- Lobster Clam Bake Special
- Fresh Fruit Smoothies
Here is the Full Menu for City Island Lobster House
Now that you know what you will be paying to eat at City Island Lobster House, here is the full menu of food options to choose from!
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
Appetizers - Cold | |
| Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (5)
| $15.95 |
| Whole Lobster in Shell (Cold)
| $18.95 |
| Scungilli Salad
| $9.95 |
| Calamari Salad
| $9.95 |
| Cold Snow Crab
| $13.95 |
| Freshly Shucked Littleneck or Cherrystone Clams
| $7.95 - $12.95 |
| Bluepoint Oysters (each)
| $1.50 |
| Seafood Salad Combo
| $13.95 |
Appetizers - Hot | |
| Buffalo Wings (9)
| $10.95 |
| Mozzarella Sticks (8)
| $8.95 |
| Fried Calamari
| $9.95 |
| Tender Chicken Fingers
| $8.95 |
| Potato Skins w/Cheese
| $6.95 |
| Potato Skins
| $8.95 |
| Oysters Rockefeller (1-2 doz.)
| $12.95 |
| Clams Oreganato (6)
| $8.95 |
| Clams Oreganato (12)
| $15.95 |
| Baked Clams Casino (6)
| $9.95 |
| Maryland Crab Cakes (2)
| $14.95 |
| Littleneck Steamers (doz.)
| $16.95 |
| Clams in Red or Garlic Sauce
| $16.95 |
| Mussels in Red or Garlic Sauce
| $14.95 |
| A Whopping Pot of Ipswich Steamers
| $23.95 |
Soup | |
| Lobster House Bisque
| $5.95 |
| New England Clam Chowder
| $5.95 |
| Manhattan Clam Chowder
| $4.95 |
Catch of the DayPrepared fresh to order. Grilled, baked, fried or sauteed. We can prepare it cajun or creole. | |
| Halibut of Swordfish
| $26.95 |
| Norwegian Salmon
| $24.95 |
| Mahi-Mahi
| $24.95 |
| Chillean Sea Bass
| $28.95 |
| Boston Scrod
| $23.95 |
| Fillet of Sole
| $24.95 |
| Whole Red Snapper
| $26.95 |
| Bluefish
| $21.95 |
| Tilapia
| $23.95 |
| Red Snapper Filet
| $24.95 |
| Broiled Seafood Combination
| $34.95 |
From our Fryer | |
| Jumbo Fried Shrimp
| $22.95 |
| Fried Sea Scallops
| $27.95 |
| Fried Yellow Tail Fillet of Sole
| $24.95 |
| Jumbo Fried Shrimp & Sea Scallops
| $28.95 |
| Tender Baby Calamari
| $19.95 |
| Authentic Fish & Chips
| $22.95 |
| Crispy Fried Maryland Soft Shell Crabs
| $26.95 |
| Freshly Shucked Fried Oysters
| $24.95 |
| Freshly Shucked Whole Fried Clams
| $24.95 |
| Fisherman's Fried Combo Platter
| $34.95 |
LobstersOur specialty fresh from maine lobster served steamed or broiled., any of our broiled lobsters can be stuffed with shrimp or crabmeat for just 12.95 per lobster | |
| Lobster
| $23.95 - $41.95 |
| 1 1/4 lb. Twin (2) Maine Lobsters
| $39.95 |
| Shell Fish Extravaganza
| $42.95 |
| Lobster House Ultimate Feast For Two
| $72.95 |
Lobster House Crab Corner | |
| King Crab Legs
| $44.95 |
| Snow Crab Leg Clusters
| $29.95 |
| Whole Blue Claw Crabs
| $25.95 |
| Jumbo Dungeness Crab Claw Clusters
| $29.95 |
| Super Crab Lovers Combination
| $69.95 |
Chilled Shellfish Sampler | |
| Chilled Shellfish Sampler
| $34.95 |
Lobster House Feasts | |
| BBQ Lobster Feast
| $69.95 |
| Don Italiano Lobster Feast
| $69.95 |
| Cold Lobster Combo
| $69.95 |
| Lobster House Crab & Lobster Feast
| $74.95 |
Lobster House Paella | |
| Paella (Serves one)
| $43.95 |
Mediterranean DishesItalian favorites all served over a bed of fresh pasta | |
| Pasta Del Mar
| $36.95 |
| Clam Sauce
| $19.95 |
| Picolla
| $23.95 |
| Calamari or Scungilli
| $21.95 |
| Shrimp Marinara
| $26.95 |
| Penne a la Vodka
| $18.95 |
| Chicken Parmigiana
| $21.95 |
| Chicken Francese
| $21.95 |
| Shrimp Parmigiana
| $24.95 |
| Sole Francese
| $24.95 |
| Penne a la Vodka
| $27.95 |
For Land Lubbers | |
| New York Shell Steak
| $26.95 |
| Thick Cut Filet Mignon 12-oz.
| $27.95 |
| Boneless Prime Rib of Beef
| $26.95 |
| Baby Back Pork Ribs & Shell Steak
| $27.95 |
| Baby Back Pork Ribs (Full Rack)
| $24.95 |
| Nice & Tender BBQ Chicken
| $18.95 |
| Baby Back Pork Ribs & Chicken
| $24.95 |
| Fried Chicken
| $18.95 |
City Island Favorites | |
| Twin Lobster Tail Platter
| $43.95 |
| Jumbo Shrimp Scampi
| $25.95 |
| Baked Scallops & Shrimp Combination
| $32.95 |
| Baked Baby Lobster Tail Platter
| $31.95 |
| Baked Day Boat Sea Scallops
| $28.95 |
| Maryland Crab Cakes
| $25.95 |
Extraordinary Combinations | |
| Whole Lobster
| $42.95 |
| Snow Crab Legs
| $34.95 |
| Lobster Tail Combo
| $42.95 |
| Broiled or Fried Shrimp Combos
| $34.95 |
| King Crab Legs
| $46.95 |
Specials | |
| 22 oz. Porter House Steak
| $29.95 |
| Surf & Turf Porter House Steak
| $44.95 |
Lobster Clam Bake SpecialAll of our lobster house entrees are served with relish tray, garlic bread, choice of caesar salad or our special house salad. Baked potato or french fries, rice or pasta and a saute of fresh garden vegetable. | |
| Lobster Clam Bake Special
| $26.95 |
Fresh Fruit Smoothies | |
| Fresh Fruit Smoothies
| $5.95 |
There Is Something For Everyone At City Island Lobster House
Now you have discovered the full menu and prices for City Island Lobster House! As you can see, there is something which will hit the spot for every customer, and the food is all incredibly reasonably priced!